Skip to content
← All work

Operations · Team building · Budget

Cutting community spend by 80% while doing more

Replaced an underperforming moderation agency with a team I hand-picked from the community: 20+ daily active moderators, multilingual cover around the clock on every platform, for a fifth of the cost.

−80%
Monthly spend, $50K to $10K
3 → 20+
Active moderators
24/7
Multilingual cover, every platform

At a glance

The problem
An expensive agency that only covered Discord, with three of its eight moderators ever active.
What I did
Built, vetted and trained an in-house team from the community, then swapped over without a gap.
The outcome
Monthly spend from $50K to $10K, with 20+ daily active moderators covering every platform 24/7.
Want the receipts? Read the full story

The receipts

The full story: context, approach, examples and results.

Context

Most of the community budget went to an outside agency. It wouldn't moderate Telegram or Reddit, its events and engagement weren't up to standard, and of the eight people on the contract we only ever saw three active. A second agency was charging a lot for a basic moderation bot. I could see the problem, but I wasn't in a position to change it until I became Head of Community.

The challenge

Replace the agency with something better and cheaper, during the busiest period the community had ever had, without members noticing a gap.

What I did

When I became Head of Community, I started building an in-house team. I hand-picked moderators from the community itself, people who already knew the product and cared about it, then vetted and trained them before they took on anything live.

Once the team was ready, around the end of October 2022, we cancelled the agency contract and handed over in one move. Members got more cover, not less: a global team working in their own languages, around the clock, on Discord, Telegram and Reddit.

We also cancelled the second agency's moderation bot. Our own custom bot took over moderation, along with translations, issue tracking and payouts.

Payouts used to go through lengthy requests to a busy finance department, so they only went out monthly. That was far too slow for a community that never sleeps. We started topping up a community wallet regularly and paying people ourselves, using the multisender I built for the team.

With the budget now in my hands, I set up approvals, tracking and regular reporting to my manager and the CFO, so every line of spend was visible.

Before and after

  • 01

    Before: the agency

    8 moderators on the contract, about 3 ever active. Discord only, with no Telegram or Reddit. Events and engagement below standard, a separate paid bot, and payouts once a month.

  • 02

    After: our own team

    20+ daily active moderators from the community, multilingual, 24/7 on every platform. Our own bot, regular payouts from a community wallet, and a fifth of the monthly cost.

Spending where it counts

Saving money on moderation made room for the things that grew the project. We attended Permissionless, Token2049 in Dubai and Singapore, and the Dubai Esports and Games Festival, hosting side events and running stalls in the event halls at each.

Each one was run as a project with clear goals, and they paid off in business development, investor interest and networking.

Results

Monthly community spend fell from $50K to $10K. The new team took over straight after our busiest period ever, the September and October 2022 launch. The handover was seamless, and the experience improved.

The community kept growing, past 150K on Discord, 170K on Telegram and 50K on Reddit, now with moderators who knew it from the inside. There was no pushback, from the community or the team.

The cheapest option and the best option turned out to be the same one: people who already cared about the community.
  • Budget
  • Hiring
  • Moderation
  • Ops